Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

hey Sk, can you please calculate my spring rate

front

Coil ID: 69mm top & bottom

Wire ID: 12.5mm

# of coils: 9.0 evenly spaced

335 lbs/inch (6.0 kg/mm)

rear

Coil ID: 71mm top & bottom

Wire ID: 11.5mm

# of coils: 9.125 evenly spaced

245 lbs/inch (4.4 kg/mm)

Thanks heaps

Cheers

Gary

  • Replies 378
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • 1 month later...

after rates for these

Coil ID = 60/60 mm

Wire OD = 10 mm

# of Coils = 6.5 turns

thanks SK :thumbsup:

no chance a simple excel doc can be made to make calculating easier on yourself and quicker for use?

Edited by Dan_J
after rates for these

Coil ID = 60/60 mm

Wire OD = 10 mm

# of Coils = 6.5 turns

thanks SK :happy:

350 lbs/inch (6.3 kg/mm)

no chance a simple excel doc can be made to make calculating easier on yourself and quicker for use?

Nope, the formula is complex and requires some knowledge to use correctly. Plus it took many years to perfect, so no one is going to give away that sort of intellectual property.

Cheers

Gary

  • 3 weeks later...
after rates for these

Coil ID = 60/60 mm

Wire OD = 10 mm

# of Coils = 6.5 turns

And just for shits and giggles, the length of steel required for that spring would be 1.44meters ;)

Edited by Luke@WSP

I'm curious to see how you work out the spring rates, Gary. I have a spreadsheet (derived from my engineering text books many years ago) which I use successfully, and it gives me much lower values than what you're quoting. Also, I note a few people have given you the spring OD, rather than the ID.

Not having a go at all. Yes, the formula is complex to the layman, but there aren't a lot of variables that can change. The modulus of rigidity is the only variable that can change, and that is pretty constant for carbon steels and alloy steels (although Stainless is different, but I don't think many of us use stainless springs, do we?)

I've just checked my calcs on two springs i have here, whose rates I know (from catalogues and shop manuals) and my calcs were very close with both of them (in fact my numbers were a bit on the high side if anything)

Also, I haven't read the ful 18 pages of this thread, but you should use the number of ACTIVE turns of the spring, not the total number of turns. That is, the number of turns that aren't in contact with the spring seat, as the metal in contact with the spring seat doesn't actually do anthing.

Again, not having a go at all, just interested to hear some real world experience. I'm happy to take this to PM, as I'm not one to try and jeopardise your business.

So you know I'm not just another internet hack, I'm a qualified mechanical engineer, with over 20 years experience and run my own consulting company. No, I don't design or make springs for a living, but have had to do several spring calculations to confimrm the correct operation of products I've been involved with over the years (most recently a major claim against a manufacturer who supplied some spring operated brakes that weren't performing to spec)

I'm curious to see how you work out the spring rates, Gary. I have a spreadsheet (derived from my engineering text books many years ago) which I use successfully, and it gives me much lower values than what you're quoting. Also, I note a few people have given you the spring OD, rather than the ID.

Yep, just take the diameter of the wire away twice from the OD and you get the ID. But you know that so, you were just testing me right?

Not having a go at all. Yes, the formula is complex to the layman, but there aren't a lot of variables that can change. The modulus of rigidity is the only variable that can change, and that is pretty constant for carbon steels and alloy steels (although Stainless is different, but I don't think many of us use stainless springs, do we?)

Yep, but dead coils, sacrificial coils, progressive wire diameter, conical coils, beehive shapes etc all make the inputs complex. As you know the skill and experience is realy needed in the input, not so much in the formulas themselves.

I've just checked my calcs on two springs i have here, whose rates I know (from catalogues and shop manuals) and my calcs were very close with both of them (in fact my numbers were a bit on the high side if anything)

OK

Also, I haven't read the ful 18 pages of this thread, but you should use the number of ACTIVE turns of the spring, not the total number of turns. That is, the number of turns that aren't in contact with the spring seat, as the metal in contact with the spring seat doesn't actually do anthing.

Yep

Again, not having a go at all, just interested to hear some real world experience. I'm happy to take this to PM, as I'm not one to try and jeopardise your business.

All I am doing is offering a no cost service in my spare time, not that there is a lot of that available. The only reason I have been doing it for over 4 years, is because I just hate guys guessing or not knowing their spring rates

So you know I'm not just another internet hack, I'm a qualified mechanical engineer, with over 20 years experience and run my own consulting company. No, I don't design or make springs for a living, but have had to do several spring calculations to confimrm the correct operation of products I've been involved with over the years (most recently a major claim against a manufacturer who supplied some spring operated brakes that weren't performing to spec)

Excellent, we should catch up somewhere, have a beer (or, as the guys know, a Jack Daniels for me) and talk technical.

Just so you know I'm also not another internet hack, I have been working with suspension on race cars for over 30 years (yes, I am that old), I hold a diploma, a degree and a masters. I designed the first 400 coil spring part numbers to start, from scratch the Whilteline Springs program in the late 90's. I actually have no idea on the number of swaybar designs that I have engineered, maybe 600 or so. I also, again started from a zero base, the Whiteline alignment products range, including the first ever caster/anti lift kits for WRX's. I worked for Jaguar for 5 years as Motorsport Manager including the successful 1984 and 1985 Bathurst campaigns. I was with the Holden Dealer Team at Bathurst in 1979 which Brocky won by 6 laps. I was also in the team in 1980 when he won by only 1 lap. Just to show the old guys still has it, earlier this year I was Team Manager and Race Engineer at the Bathurst 12 Hour where we came 1st and 2nd in Class. That'll do, I could go on for pages, best to stop now.

I'm serious about the catch up and a drink

Cheers

Gary

  • 1 month later...

I got some springs which have markings on them 62 180 008 and 62 200 006, now from measuring the first two relate to IN Dia and height respectively in mm, so the last numbers I'm guessing refer to spring rate (8kg/mm and 6kg/mm), which is not what these springs were meant to be.

My measurements are:

FR:

Coil ID top and bottom - 62mm

Wire OD - 11mm

# of Coils - 6.5

RR:

Coil ID top and bottom - 62mm

Wire OD - 11mm

# of coils- 7.5

The # of coils depends how you look at it but this is close enough to give me a good idea of whether I was sent the right springs or not. Thanks for any help Gary!

  • 1 month later...
165 lbs/inch (3 kg/mm R33 front standards)

Cheers

Gary

Any idea what they would be with a coil cut off them?

also dose anyone have the measurement or specs of whiteline r31 springs? then I need to know what the spec would be with a coil cut off them

Plz no one flame about cutting coils being dodgy and to just buy good springs. there's a good reason for me to be asking.

I didnt cut them but they seem to be a good rate so I want to know what specs to be after when/ if I change

Edited by lawler
  • 1 month later...
  • 1 month later...
  • 1 month later...

From what I can tell, Sydneykid no longer operates regularly on these forums. Hence all the rates which have been asked have been left unanswered.

Using the engineering text books I have and used to build racecar suspension, I can calculate you rates. If you need a quick answer, just send me a PM and Ill plug it into my spreadsheet and give you an answer as quick as possible.

For example:

Dan J

Using the inputs you gave me the spring rate is 7.08 kg/mm or 396.5 lb/in

Cheers,

David

  • 6 months later...

Ok ive read most of this thread, luv it, and i am looking for advice.

Got a r32 gtst, very hard, very low. Im looking for a good set of new coilovers, for the whole cars springs and all.

The rides too hard, the shocks are shagged,

Decided im getting beilstens but as for the springs, have no idea what to ask for.

I want a soft ride! City driving, brissys shit streets, no track.

So what is stock spring rates for this car??

  • 8 months later...

Ok ive read most of this thread, luv it, and i am looking for advice.

Got a r32 gtst, very hard, very low. Im looking for a good set of new coilovers, for the whole cars springs and all.

The rides too hard, the shocks are shagged,

Decided im getting beilstens but as for the springs, have no idea what to ask for.

I want a soft ride! City driving, brissys shit streets, no track.

So what is stock spring rates for this car??

I would aim for ~4kg max at the front for a street car, rear I am not too sure, fix your roll with sway bars, not stiffer springs. Perhaps post a thread asking this specific question as I don't think many people still read this thread.

Also don't lower the car too much, it stuffs up the geometry.

Edited by Rolls

I have this Tein S Tech spring instruction (in Japanese), from what I can tell, it lists both front & rear as 2.2. (c.f. S tech soft, front 2.9-3.2 & rear 2.2-2.9 and medium 2.8-4.2 & 1.8-3.6)

  • 7 months later...

SydneyKid, are you still doing this?

If so I would like to no roughly what my rates are.

Just Fronts at this stage. Done in-car so sorry for the OD measurements.

Wire OD - 12.28mm

Top of Coil OD- 127.7mm

Bottom of Coil OD- 90.61mm

Starts to taper smaller at the 5th coil down.

No. of Coils- 9.125

Also, seeing as I have read a few other suspension threads and you seem to be the "guru", would you mind looking at these pictures and telling me if its Mono tube and also are those grooves under the seat the circlip grooves I have read about?

Also there's a reference picture there for the Coil taper.

Whole Strut.

http://i888.photobuc...en/be1c40df.jpg

Taper.

http://i888.photobuc...en/3360d864.jpg

Grooves?

http://i888.photobuc...en/0cf19255.jpg

Thanks SK :)

Ben

Edited by TrikkBen

SydneyKid, are you still doing this?

If so I would like to no roughly what my rates are.

Just Fronts at this stage. Done in-car so sorry for the OD measurements.

Wire OD - 12.28mm

Top of Coil OD- 127.7mm

Bottom of Coil OD- 90.61mm

Starts to taper smaller at the 5th coil down.

No. of Coils- 9.125

Also, seeing as I have read a few other suspension threads and you seem to be the "guru", would you mind looking at these pictures and telling me if its Mono tube and also are those grooves under the seat the circlip grooves I have read about?

Also there's a reference picture there for the Coil taper.

Whole Strut.

http://i888.photobuc...en/be1c40df.jpg

Taper.

http://i888.photobuc...en/3360d864.jpg

Grooves?

http://i888.photobuc...en/0cf19255.jpg

Thanks SK :)

Ben

Ill calculate your spring rates when I get home. At work and my spreadsheet etc. is not on this computer.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • just an update to this, poor man pays twice  Tried sanding down the pulleys but it didnt do the trick. Chucked another second hand alternator in the na car which I got for free off my mate and its fixed the squelling. Must have been unlucky with the bearings.    As for my turbo car, I managed to pick up a cwc rb alternator conversion bracket + LS alternator for 250 off marketplace, looked to be in really good nick. Installed it , started the car and its not charging the battery.... ( Im not good with auto elec stuff so im not sure if this was all I needed to do but I verified such by using a multimeter on the battery when the engine was running and I was only getting 12.2v )   I had to modify the earth strap for the new LS alternator , factory earth strap was a 10mm bolt which did not fit the bolt on the LS alternator which was double the size so I cut it off , went to repco bought some ring terminals that fit, crimped it onto the old earth strap and bolted it up to the alternator , started the car and same issue. Ran like shit and was reading 12.2 at the battery.  For a "plug and play" advertised kit thats not very plug and play but alas.  My question is , am I missing something ? Ive been reading that some people recommend upgrading the stock 80 amp alternator fuse to a 140 amp but I dont see how that would stop the alternator charging especially at idle not under load.  Regardless ive pulled it out and am going to get it bench tested by an auto elec tomorrow but it would be handy to know if ive missed something silly or have done something wrong.   
    • My wild guess is that you have popped off an intake pipe....check all of the hoses between the turbo and the throttle for splits or loose clamps.
    • Awesome, thanks for sharing!
    • To provide more specific help, more information is needed. What Android screen? What is its wiring diagram? Does the car's wiring have power at any required BAT and ACC wires, and is the loom's earth good?
    • So, now all you need to do is connect the 2 or 3x 12v feeds into the unit to permanent 12v, ACC 12V and IGN 12V that you can find in the spot behind the stereo, and the earth, and then it will switch on with the car.
×
×
  • Create New...