Jump to content
SAU Community

i blame  

27 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

really, you didnt look too hard then.. cause the 17bil plus figure has been thrown around alot.. As Aaron said, 8bil was just the first stage Hoddle st to citylink...to get a similar return form tolls as citylink would require a 30$ toll just for this section...

first link i clicked on

http://www.smh.com.au/business/if-you-thought-using-a-toll-road-was-costly-try-building-one-20140811-102i5o.html

(Its the age so take its credibility with a grain of salt :P)

anyway its beyond the point... 8-10 billion is jsut as ridiculous when a normal road would cost a tenth of that..this is an excercise in vanity at the expense of every other Victorian that doesnt give a rats ass about how pretty Melbourne city is...eastlink cost 1B, citylink costs 1.8B...can you imagine the traffic flow if we built 10 more eastlink type motorways...sure you might have to drive around the city not through it, but thats alot of nice driving roads going everywhere vs one shitty smoke filled tunnel going nowhere....

Think about it, we can build high speed Autobahns all around the city for this type of money..

Edited by ARTZ

Still 'estimates' from some guy..

"Direct comparisons are fraught as some projects are still in the planning stage, others were completed some time ago and the more costly projects have high tunnelling costs"

nice disclaimer to kick off his analysis may as well have said this is an opinion piece with little to no proof of the cost estimate

It's going to happen sooner or later labor has just wasted the money they need a road solution more trains doesn't mean squat for a majority of the population. I have stepped foot on public transport In decade and no amount of money or convenience could entice me back to it

I call bullshit on it's inevitability. And even if it is, it's still not a good investment at this point in time. Spend the money on projects which will give a better return. Once it works it's way to the top of the pile from a CBA perspective then build it.

Regarding public transport, just because you don't use it doesn't mean it's no good. There are loooots of people who rely on public transport and lots who would, if it were more accessible. A rail line out to Mernda would take thousands of cars off the road daily in the north east and even the Eastern. My brother in law is fairly typical of people out that way. He works for Telstra and has almost no option but to drive. The car parks at any station within cooee are full by 6:30am so he drives to work in the city. If he was within walking distance, or an acceptable push bike trip to a station he would catch the train. There are lots and lots of people like him on those outer suburbs.

For what it's worth it was labor who back flipped on the last lot of road tolling after promising not too.. Spose they'd figure half a billion for nothin is cheap compared to a billion dollar desal plant that's never been turned on

And the day it is turned on we'll all be very glad it's there. The desal plant is an insurance policy. We'll go through another drought within the next decade and by then we'll be housing another 1-1.5 million people in Melbourne. The pressure on water storage will be just too much. More dams is a stupid idea because at the end of the day they still require rain. We can't rely on rainfall any more for long term water security.

And the day it is turned on we'll all be very glad it's there. The desal plant is an insurance policy. We'll go through another drought within the next decade and by then we'll be housing another 1-1.5 million people in Melbourne. The pressure on water storage will be just too much. More dams is a stupid idea because at the end of the day they still require rain. We can't rely on rainfall any more for long term water security.

Its funny how quickly people forget how close this city was coming to having no water supply... ;)

May as well turn it on now and start pumping water out to arrid parts of australia that need it...better farming, more revenue from produce, pays for desal...win win

It was a useful project, Having it sitting there doing nothing is the waste of money....

Edited by ARTZ

Still 'estimates' from some guy..

"Direct comparisons are fraught as some projects are still in the planning stage, others were completed some time ago and the more costly projects have high tunnelling costs"

nice disclaimer to kick off his analysis may as well have said this is an opinion piece with little to no proof of the cost estimate

Yeah, just some guy.

The libs refused to release basically any info regarding the cost of the EWL so "some guy" had to use the figures at his disposal.

Again, this was stage one. Stage two, from Citylink to the Ring Road, would be an even bigger and more expensive project, so $10B for that stage is probably quite conservative.

May as well turn it on now and start pumping water out to arrid parts of australia that need it...better farming, more revenue from produce, pays for desal...win win

It was a useful project, Having it sitting there doing nothing is the waste of money....

I'd be all for a couple billion dollars of the money saved by scrapping the EWL be used to pipe water out to rural areas that could use it to irrigate for farming.

It's not a waste of money, it's an insurance policy. Well, it's not a waste in so far as insurance is not a waste. Personally I hate insurance, paying the premium each year sucks balls, but if you ever need it you sure are glad you have it.

But it was never really designed to 'pay itself off'

it was designed to stop us running out of water to live with

This costs money, just like insurance costs money

Meh. I prefered the simple pipe under bass straight idea, run from Tassie's overflowing dams it would flow continuously, without power, for hundreds of years. Unfortunately the government knew they couldn't jack the price of water up as much with this solution.

  • Like 1

Meh. I prefered the simple pipe under bass straight idea, run from Tassie's overflowing dams it would flow continuously, without power, for hundreds of years. Unfortunately the government knew they couldn't jack the price of water up as much with this solution.

What happens when you end up with a government in Tassie who doesn't like the government in Victoria? What happens when climate change reduces the abundance of Tassie water to the point they can no longer supply mainland Australia? How much would the pipeline have cost to build and then maintain?

Desal is the best insurance policy for water security. Regarding the power required, the ALP legislated to fund enough wind to power it plus some therefore negating it's CO2 output. The libs quashed this.

  • Like 1

What happens when you end up with a government in Tassie who doesn't like the government in Victoria? What happens when climate change reduces the abundance of Tassie water to the point they can no longer supply mainland Australia? How much would the pipeline have cost to build and then maintain?

err i got nothing 'gainst you cowboy... but umm there is already something called Bass Link.

Underwater DC cable that tassie supplies to victoria (for a profit during peak loading) due to their abundance of hydro generators. and unfortunately a lot of the time these sorts of decisions arent made by government, just allowed by them, because there are private companies that generally plan and research these sorts of ideas. and make sure theyre profitable and generally keep most people happy.

...unlike the desal.

Are you still on That bandwagon Alex.

Dont care if its 8 or 18 or 10.7 , its not justified..

How about spend a billion building a road and a billion relocating everything in its path... There I just saved Victoria 8 billion dollars...give or take...

Tunnels are shit...

Edited by ARTZ

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • My dream is also to have a proper hoist, but I don't think it will ever happen. My quickjack is probably as close as I'll ever get, it really is very good though. 
    • Yeah we keep on in the dailies, it is pretty poor how many animals get hit and the driver leaves without checking....have saved a couple of little ones over the years. Bit of a gruesome job though, pouches generally need to be cut open because they are so tight and often the joey doesn't realise mum is gone so they are still locked onto the teat. I checked the modules in front of the DS wheel where an oil cooler should go.... There is the radar unit - that can go for race use) One of the 2 HX water pumps, the silver cylinder. That needs to be kept but might be able to be relocated But the bad news, the big computer mounted vertically in front of the wheel (blocking any potential air exit) is the electric steering computer. That is required until/unless i do a hydraulic steering conversion, and in CAD based modern car design it is not like I can just pop a big unit like that somewhere else (plus the loom would be too short anywhere else too). So, the passenger side is OK to clear out (just use a smaller washer reservoir, potentially elsewhere), but the DS no beuno
    • Well, all the best with the new camry It was interesting to hear about the UK process, it is generally a lot more streamlined here with a shipping agent looking after all the import side (noting the exact final price can still be a surprise.....) and I've used a few different brokers on the japan (or US) side, and never had any trouble with any of them....luck of the draw I guess. You mentioned you didn't get the auction sheet (understandable since you bought it from a dealer, not auction), but I always try and get hold of that because they are pretty thorough. I've imported 2x R grade vehicles over the years and both were fine, repairs in Japan are pretty thorough compared to here in Oz.
    • BTW I measured the jack I have, it is 70mm at the saddle but you only have about 700 until it returns to 150mm high at the cylinder so it is good but no magic bullet.
    • My experience with Rising Sun Exports Before agreeing to the sale I tried to do as much research as I could (obviously), his Facebook reviews are 98% and he goes Live at least once or twice a week. I contacted 2 people in the UK who had used him for their imports, both had positive feedback. His explanation and talk through of the import process was thorough, answering any query no matter how stupid it was. It felt as soon as the money was sent, communication dropped off. I asked for shipping updates every 2 weeks or so, not wanting to pester him, he never had any updates. I wasn't informed the car had been dropped off at the port, I only found out by his Facebook story. I asked for the photos taken at the port, knowing he would need some for insurance purposes. I received a few 5 second clips and that's it. When asked again, he said his staff had them. Weeks later I asked again, he tells me he doesn't have any, but does have 50 photos from the original advert. I never received them. I eventually got the documents sent via WhatsApp after I mentioned the port was requesting them. I purchased a CarVX report, to find out the vehicle is a Grade R with recorded accident damage, first recorded in 2017 when it was first auctioned. He never told me the grade, then again I didn't ask. His response was "Grade R means nothing, it wasn't chassis damage". Still, I would have liked to have been informed about it. Jon prides himself on being open and honest when it comes to inspecting cars, it's his main job doing so at the auctions for customers. When the vehicle arrived in the UK I noticed a few little cosmetic issues. It's a 21 year old car so it wasn't going to be mint condition. The side skirts are cracked on each corner and the sealant is failing. The front grill on the bonnet/hood isn't secured very well, mounting studs are missing. Both minor things, but again, it would have been nice to be told. During a Facebook Live walk around video of the vehicle, he mentioned it has a front Whiteline anti roll bar/sway bar. While on the inspection ramp, I noticed the stock item has been installed. When first questioned, his response was "the ARB? Switched? Since when, it never had them". Since sending video and photo evidence I've not received a response. I'm probably being over critical of the overall condition of an old car, but all I wanted was honesty (which he claims to have). I'm aware I wasn't his only customer, he's busy doing XYZ but other reviews praise him for great communication with regular updates and photos, I felt I didn't receive the same treatment. 
×
×
  • Create New...