Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

i dont get the flames part

my brother bought an r32gtst which got through compliance with no cat anywhere. it never shot flames, backfired, made black soot or smelt bad. but there was absolutely no cat on it

a year later he got a hi flow metal cat. only difference now is that the note is apparently different, -but i cant tell.

Oh and he wont get a $10k fine

  • Replies 43
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Just make sure if you do knock it out you put a straight pipe through the cat or it will more than likely lose you power.

I agree with some of the comments and disagree with others, if your making less that 220rwkw's i do believe its pointless and not worth the gains. I have now put a 3" pipe through my cat and to me the Pro's were: a good 10-15kw power gain and boost definitely comes on earlier with less back pressure. The cons are my rear bumper is always black and it definitely made my car louder and dronier!

Interested if any one is running a cat with launch control antilag thingo

such as the Bee*R, powerfc pro etc did it blow your cat to pieces?

Have been thinking I would have to go for a decat pipe if I end up running antilag launchcontrol

so curious if anyone else has had any issue's

Thx for the input, you guys love your flames, i didnt know it would blow flames, was just asking in regards to having a bit more power and also coz i dont have and wont have a spare dollar any time soon to buy a cat. Might just leave the one i got as i have a kit fitted and car is getting resprayed next week, dont wanna burn that fresh paint.

This is what I noticed:

1. sound didn't get much louder at all.

2. power increase was a fair bit. For the person who said smashing it will make less power, sure if you get 3" pipe welded through it, it'll have more power, but it's not exactly going to rob power if you smash it out without putting pipe inside. Think of it as a small muffler (cat body) compared to having a plug in your exhaust (cat). It still made quite a difference smashing it.

3. bumper didn't really get any dirtier. Our cars run a bit rich anyways, so the bumper naturally gets a little soot on it. Didn't make anymore soot.

4. smells? not really hey. Exhaust fumes normally stink and of course you shoudlnt' breath them in normally - carbon monoxide. I didn't notice it being more smellier after.

4. flames - come on guys, it's not like it's flaming 24/7 or something. it's not like it flames on idle or something. It flames if you're absoloutely killing it and evyerthing's really hot. If you've been hitting it, and if you let go at wot, then it might flame. The flame is really quick, and it never really burnt anything of mine (doesn't really get near it, just striaght out.

The power difference between no cat and hiflow cat is not that much if you have a decent hiflow cat. and definitely not worth the risk of a $10,000 fine!

I had a 3" cat-bypass pipe made to replace my 3" Metal cat (thats the brand) for testing purpose. It only gained 6rwkw on the dyno and my car was running 250rwkw+ at the time. It would have made even less of a difference for a lesser power car.

Knocking Out Cat Guts? Not worth the effort and risk.

bunch of hippies i reckon haha

From my experience i've noticed that:

1. it will make a difference to performance, and if you have a stock 10-15 year old cat in your car that is most likely cloged and melted together then you will gain a nice amount of power.

2. Your car will be slightly louder but nothing crazy, no where near the extent of taking out one muffler.

3. I have seen plenty of cars with no cats what so ever pass the emitions test with flying colours.

For example, my celica had a 3inch hiflow cat, i decided to put in a 3inch decat (looks kinda like a cat but its hollow), notice a very small difference but this would be because i already had a nice flowing cat. Anyway i had to get my plates changed from QLD to WA and i forgot that i had left the decat on it. Passed visual inspections cause the guy was a retard and it also passed the emissions test. This was a car that i hadnt tuned yet and was running the very rich base map tune, and the exhaust consisted of straight pipe and onehks cannon. No dramas...

bunch of hippies i reckon haha

From my experience i've noticed that:

1. it will make a difference to performance, and if you have a stock 10-15 year old cat in your car that is most likely cloged and melted together then you will gain a nice amount of power.

2. Your car will be slightly louder but nothing crazy, no where near the extent of taking out one muffler.

3. I have seen plenty of cars with no cats what so ever pass the emitions test with flying colours.

For example, my celica had a 3inch hiflow cat, i decided to put in a 3inch decat (looks kinda like a cat but its hollow), notice a very small difference but this would be because i already had a nice flowing cat. Anyway i had to get my plates changed from QLD to WA and i forgot that i had left the decat on it. Passed visual inspections cause the guy was a retard and it also passed the emissions test. This was a car that i hadnt tuned yet and was running the very rich base map tune, and the exhaust consisted of straight pipe and onehks cannon. No dramas...

The problem is not every "visual inspector" or policemen that pulls you over would be retard. If the police gets a metal wire into your rear end and find it straight though, you're busted. They wouldn't care if your car passes emissions or not.

Anyone who's been around cars a few years can tell straight away if it has a working cat or not - the smell is completely different . As for flames from the exhaust ? shouldn't be doing that with or without a converter - its not there to be a flame or spark trap . If the EFI system is injecting fuel when it shouldn't something is very wrong or the load/airflow sensing device is sending the computer the wrong messages .

Just about everyones got a family and they have to breathe as well .

As for unleaded avaition fuel (Av gas) , this is far from the best fuel to run from purely a performance point of view .

Any responsable person will run a working converter and high flowing ones are a buy bolt affair nowdays .

Every mug that gets busted takes us closer to the day when the RTA will have road side sniffers and the simple cheap light type road side gas analyser . Think about it , you may pass the RBT test/noise test/computer rego check/visual height check etc but if they have a cheap means of sniffing the exhaust (particularly if there's signs of soot and blistered paint) your going to be general revenue's best friend .

The authorities LOVE making examples of people driving performance and import cars . For all of our sakes can you please do the right thing .

Cheers A .

I have a hollow cat and the cops are so retarded they tried to tell me i "had no cat". Had to point it out to them.

If you wana do it, farkin do it, you run the risk, we aint yo mamma :(

What do you mean hollow cat is that a brand? Even if you have a cat with the guts punched out they will still be able to pick it up by putting a probe in the end of the exhaust then they will probe you with a nice fine. Anyway i had a hollow cat as old mate puts it, and when i changed it to a a proper highflow cat i notcied no difference whats so ever with performance, the exhaust note was just a tad bit quiter. And yes its definatley not worth the trouble and the risks you run.

"For example, my celica had a 3inch hiflow cat, i decided to put in a 3inch decat (looks kinda like a cat but its hollow), notice a very small difference but this would be because i already had a nice flowing cat. Anyway i had to get my plates changed from QLD to WA and i forgot that i had left the decat on it. Passed visual inspections cause the guy was a retard and it also passed the emissions test. This was a car that i hadnt tuned yet and was running the very rich base map tune, and the exhaust consisted of straight pipe and onehks cannon. No dramas..."

I would be very curious to see what emissions test that passed? There isnt one with a blue slip

I bashed out my cat, slightly deeper note, no noticeable increase in power or response, probably not worth the effort IMO. I don't get any flames, a bit of a smell but thats it. Its worth checking your cat, if it looks screwed, change it or bash it, if it looks okay, then leave it be.

You can always pick a car that has no cat when traveling behind...

Cops aren't totally stupid either, if something smells odd they'll make no hesitation in pulling you over and either defecting you on the spot or sending you in for a machinery.

Best bet get a good quality metallic cat converter :P

Keep your old cat for when you need to put it back on for EPA purposes. Go and purchase an old commodore cat, doesn't matter the condition it's in. Go to a workshop and have them weld flanges on to a three inch pipe. Now with the commodore cat you have purchased get them to unpick the outer shell off and weld this over the pipe. Now obviously the side with the small holes in it goes upwards. Now you have a high flow cat. Enjoy

You guys seem to be missing the point that these 'hi flow cats' are bloody expensive.

mickr33 has the right idea, and i doubt the cops would carry a 3m long piece of wire around just to stick up your pipe which has 2 90 degree bends in a row :wub:

Just pop it out. Everyone knows flames are cool and the earth is dying anyway.

If youre worried about emissions then dont drive a car.

  • 1 month later...

i've been considering this myself. :

pros

possible performance/responsiveness gain

possible flames (you know you want em!)

slightly tougher sound

FREE!! - sure we would all like to swap to a nice hi-flow metallic cat, but who wants to pay for one?

cons

possibly more damaging to the environment - although i doubt the people that site this as a reason not to 'punch your cat' are out lobbying to all motorsport leagues to put cats on their race cars, or trading in their high perfomance cars for electrics...

possibility of a fine - heaps of the mods people carry out on this forum are potentially fine-able, though this is definitely not a light issue. in the end its up to you, i'm sure we all occasionally breach the laws (speeding etc) by accident :thumbsup: which is also a risk we take. plus now i think they can impound your car (in many parts of QLD anyway) which could make 'swapping to a proper cat for an emissions test' difficult??

like someone said, we aint yo' mumma. and we aint paying your fines so the choice, as always, is yours!

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Actually, that's not entirely true. It's also the same motor in the 1st gen Nissan Cube but they're rare as hen's teeth.  
    • Yeah it is always worth testing and balancing actuators out of the box, just set the pressure regulator on a compressor very low (eg 5 psi) and increase it slowly to see when they both move.....unfortunately while you may be able to adjust the length of the actuator rod to minimise any difference, the actual pressure they move from is not adjustable so you need a well matched pair. And yes, the VCAM is probably contributing; the earlier in the rev range they come on boost and the slower the revs build (I think your demo was in 5th), the more you notice it.  Driving at WOT through 1st, 2nd, 3rd etc you will probably never hear it as any shuffling starts and is over super quickly
    • oh they were with that motor, you need to remove the engine to change the spark plugs (don't have to, but it does make it easier)
    • I certainly fall into the annoyed camp, but glad to hear that if it's happening at low boost then I'm not likely going to blow a turbo and end up with metal shards in my oil. Just feels like it prevents me from really driving it without hesitation and "peak" performance. Wonder if it's the VCAM, it did an impressive job of shifting the torque curve and faster spool, but maybe now it's "too fast" and there's too much air for how open the throttle is.  Based on some other threads, will also do some reading on synchronizing the actuators. They are the default actuators that come on the Garrett's and I would think they would be set the same coming from the factory, but if the turbos don't actually work exactly the same way at the same time as previously mentioned, it would be worth making sure the actuators are actuating together properly
    • I went down this rabbit hole before, ended up sourcing a motor from the UK (I'm in Japan) which also didn't function correctly. With the original motor, I disassembled it and reassembled it and it works somewhat, sometimes. What I could deduce from all my screwing around is that there is calibration of the gears on the inside of the motor and two ramps on the main gear which activate switches that operate the motor and move the sunroof either to retract into the roof or tilt. Where I got stuck was that, it seemed in my case that one or both of the switches that are activated by the ramp on the gear did not always activate and thus the motor did not move, causing it to sometimes not retract or tilt (apologies, I've forgotten which way it didn't work.).  Of course this part is discontinued at Nissan now, it's the same part in the S15 but no other models. I also contacted the manufacturer of the component for schematics - forgot the name, they're based in Gifu - but they declined to share the information due to being bound by an NDA, sadly. Looking through my pictures now, it seems I last had a crack at this in 2022. See, I so kindly wrote "open" and "close" next to the switches. If you figure it out, please do tell me. Those little switches, with the red buttons may need to be replaced.
×
×
  • Create New...