Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Its getting time to buy my wife a replacement car from her Mitsubishi RVR Supersports. I get a great deal on diesel, so petrol is out of the question. There are so many cars that sort of suit the criteria, but having been out of the trade for 5 years, i dont have a lot of experience with these newer cars.

Not looking for anything small-must fit 3 baby seats,but not massive(ie not a Prado) and prefer somthing highish for safety visability.

Second hand, but under about 5 years, will spend up to 30, but prefer about 20k

Some of the options:

Captiva 7

Hyundai IX 35

BMWx3

BMW 320d

Skoda Octavia

Volvo v70 diesel(only seen 1)

Hyundai I30 wagon( A bit small)

VW Passat wagon

Nissan xtrail

Peugot 407 Wagon

Cherry(not)

Kia(also not too keen)

Audi A4 wagon

Audi Q5

Audi Allroad 2004

Ford mondeo TDCi wagon

Hyundai Santa Fe

Citroen C5(eek)

Any Advise appreciated

  • Replies 51
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Leave the Audi Allroad alone, slow as all get out.

The Audi A4 with the 3.0TDi is a fking cracker, I was very impressed with it.

My wife has a Jetta 2.0TDi, goes great and is excellent on fuel. The missus loves it.

The Audi will be worth more when you come to trade it.

Do not do anything with the Citrus, fkn shit heap.

Forrester TDi or an Outback?? Get a lot of car for the money.

I'd go Audi or BMW, if that's your short list, but only is she deserves it.

Audi have really come a long way with technology, performance and reliability.

They're such a large company now, brilliant cars.

I'm looking at Alfa Romeos for my wife.

Alfas have also improved a lot, however their electronic transmission hasn't.

The 159 wagon looks good.

Always had a small spot in my heart for Alfa, after having a Sprint and GTV.

Always nice to drive.

Its getting time to buy my wife a replacement car from her Mitsubishi RVR Supersports. I get a great deal on diesel, so petrol is out of the question. There are so many cars that sort of suit the criteria, but having been out of the trade for 5 years, i dont have a lot of experience with these newer cars.

Not looking for anything small-must fit 3 baby seats,but not massive(ie not a Prado) and prefer somthing highish for safety visability.

Second hand, but under about 5 years, will spend up to 30, but prefer about 20k

Some of the options:

Captiva 7

Hyundai IX 35

BMWx3

BMW 320d

Skoda Octavia

Volvo v70 diesel(only seen 1)

Hyundai I30 wagon( A bit small)

VW Passat wagon

Nissan xtrail

Peugot 407 Wagon

Cherry(not)

Kia(also not too keen)

Audi A4 wagon

Audi Q5

Audi Allroad 2004

Ford mondeo TDCi wagon

Hyundai Santa Fe

Citroen C5(eek)

Any Advise appreciated

Mate if your after a <5 year old car, then some of the cars on your list will be more than 30k. Audi A4 Diesel Wagon is 32k, Q5 diesel is 60k, current shape Mondeo TDCi wagon is 33k. If it were my money I would go the VW Passat wagon if it had to be a diesel under 30k, heres a car sales link to a good one. I wouldnt bother with the Captiva of all the people i knew who had them they all had problems and in my experience are POS.

Other than being slowish, (9.5 0-100) The audi allroad looks like a good thing, dont really care about performance though. They are $110,000 new

Say that to yourself when you want to overtake something, seriously, dont do it.

I'd go Audi or BMW, if that's your short list, but only is she deserves it.

Audi have really come a long way with technology, performance and reliability.

They're such a large company now, brilliant cars.

I'm looking at Alfa Romeos for my wife.

Alfas have also improved a lot, however their electronic transmission hasn't.

The 159 wagon looks good.

Always had a small spot in my heart for Alfa, after having a Sprint and GTV.

Always nice to drive.

They are awesome at catching on fire.

oddly enough, just out of the ones you listed Id be tempted to take the Mondeo. they're butt ugly but are very useable..

or I would look for a forester as well, great little all round car for the money and fun in gravel or a little off roading..

I have very similar requirements for our new car and the test drive list was something like this:

Skoda superb

BMW X1

Nissan Xtrail

VW Passat

Passat wins.

Differences were that we are buying new, and it only has to fit 2 baby seats.

all the rest aren't worth the money or are crap rolled in sprinkles.

I would still revisit the prado (esp for the 3 baby seats) ...the 80/100 series landcruiser are the bigger of the 4wd for yotas

internally they look visibly narrower than an allroad.

avoid santa fe (unstable on highways imo) and captiva (build quality issues)

foresters will be a squeeze (from my experience) for 3 baby seats (unless someone coughs up with internal dimensions)

Edited by jaxt

oh i missed the bit about 3 kids.

Another option I considered for the missus was getting a crewcab 2wd hilux. They have plenty of go, plenty of room inside plus a huge tray for a boot and they look sweet with 20 inch wheels of a falcon on them. Problem is at 700km a tank they're no more economical than most petrol sedans.

oh i missed the bit about 3 kids.

Another option I considered for the missus was getting a crewcab 2wd hilux. They have plenty of go, plenty of room inside plus a huge tray for a boot and they look sweet with 20 inch wheels of a falcon on them. Problem is at 700km a tank they're no more economical than most petrol sedans.

plus they bounce around like all fark because they are designed to carry a work load not children. Hardly a safe alternative.

Mates, colleagues and family members (one who runs a fleet of 1k+ cars) have had nothing but trouble with VWs and Audis. I like them, but I'm not sure if I'd like to own one.

My BMW is sweet.

No matter which way you go, be wary of particulate filter problems in diesel models of various manufacturers.

And generally speaking, I've found the Japanese stuff better on maintenance overall.

you're not the only one who finds jap stuff more reliable than European. But when it comes to oilers they make good ones (if you give them the right fuel).

I'd go with Polo 1.9 for cheap.

Other than being slowish, (9.5 0-100) The audi allroad looks like a good thing, dont really care about performance though. They are $110,000 new

Say that to yourself when you want to overtake something, seriously, dont do it.

My dad's auto Corolla is even slower (0 - 100, 11.4 seconds) & I've have no problem overtaking...

I30 is my pick, basic A - B transport.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Cheers. Skyline is back on the menu, can’t get rid of it. It’s like a child you don’t want, or herpes 
    • I got back to Japan in January and was keen to get back on track as quickly as possible. Europe is god-awful for track accessibility (by comparison), so I picked up a first-gen GT86 in December just to have something I could jump into right away. The Skyline came over in a container this time and landed in early January. It was a bit battered after Europe, though—I refused to do anything beyond essential upkeep while it was over there. The clutch master cylinder gave out, and so did the power steering. I didn’t even bother changing the oil; it was the same stuff that went in just before I left Japan the first time. Naughty. Power steering parts would’ve cost double with shipping and taxes, so knowing I’d be heading back to Japan, I just postponed it and powered through the arm workout. It took a solid three months to get the car back on the road. Registration was a nightmare this time around. There were a bunch of BS fees to navigate, and sourcing parts was a headache. I needed stock seats for shaken, mistakenly blew 34k JPY on some ENR34 seats—which, of course, didn’t fit—then ended up having the car’s technical sheet amended to register it as a two-seater with the Brides. Then there’s the GT86. Amazing car. Does everything I want it to do. Parts are cheap, easy to find, and I don’t care what anyone says—it’s super rewarding to drive. I’ve done a few basic mods: diff ratio, coilovers, discs, pads, seat, etc. It already had a new exhaust manifold and the 180kph limiter removed, so I assume it’s running some kind of map. I’ve just been thrashing it at the track non-stop—mostly Fuji Speedway now, since I need something with higher speed after all that autobahn time. The wheels on the R34 always pissed me off—too big, and it was a nightmare getting tires to fit properly under the arches. So I threw in the towel and bought something that fits better. Looks way cleaner too (at least to me)—less hotboy, less attention-seeking. Still an R34, though. Now for future plans. There are a few things still outstanding with the car. First up, the rear subframe needs an overhaul—that’s priority one. Next, I need to figure out an engine rebuild plan. No timeline yet, but I want to keep it economical—not cutting corners, just not throwing tens of thousands at a mechanic I can barely communicate with. And finally, paint. Plus a bit of tidying up here and there.  
    • Nope, needed to clearance under the bar a little with a heat gun, a 1/2" extension as the "clearancer", and big hammer, I was aware of this from the onset, they fit a 2.0 with this intake no problems, but, the 2.5 is around 15mm taller than a 2.0, so "clearancing" was required  It "just" touched when test fitting, now, I have about 10mm of clearance  You cannot see where it was done, and so far, there's no contact when giving it the beans Happy days
    • It's been a while since I've updated this thread. The last year (and some) has been very hectic. In the second-half of 2024 I took the R34 on a trip through Germany, Italy, France and Switzerland - it was f*cking great. I got a little annoyed with the attention the car was getting around Europe and really didn't drive it that much. I could barely work on the car since I was living in an inner-city apartment (with underground parking). During the trip, the car lost power steering in France - split hose - and I ended up driving around 4,000kms with no power steering.  There were a few Nurburgring trips here and there, but in total the R34 amassed just shy of 7,000kms on European roads. Long story short, I broke up with the reason I was transferred to Europe for and requested to be moved back to Japan. The E90, loved it. It was a sunk cost of around EUR 10,000 and I sold it to a friend for EUR 1,500 just to get rid of it quickly. Trust me, moving countries f*cking sucks and I could not be bothered to be as methodical as I was the first time around.
×
×
  • Create New...