Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Had a turbo swap done from twins to single with some other parts replace (below). Before I brought it to the shop to start the work, I had to compression tested and results were C1-115, C2-118, C3-119, C4-121, C5-119, C6-119. Half way through the work we found a problem and had to get more parts so the car sat for about 8-9 months without starting it. When they finally had everything sorted and put it on the dyno, it was only making around ~260hp at 15psi with an HKS GT3-4r. They compression tested it after and results were C1-70, C2-90, C3-100, C4-100, C5-100, C6-100. They think that the reason it isn't making power is because of the low compression, and they think the low compression could be due to it sitting for months or the engine just waring down. They think there's a chance that compression could come back after driving it for a couple weeks, if not they are suggesting a rebuild. 

Any suggestion on what could have caused compression to drop so much suddenly? Anything in particular to check? Could it actually be from the car sitting for 8-9 months?

Mods done:
HKS GT3-4r
HKS Manifold
HKS Downpipe
HKS Fuel Rail
HKS Fuel Pump
HKS Coil packs
HKS BOV
ID 1050x injectors
Tomei Fuel Pressure Regulator
Greddy Boost Controller
Platinum Pro ECU

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/482713-rb26-low-power-and-low-compression/
Share on other sites

On 8/7/2021 at 1:56 PM, SnekDoc said:

They think that the reason it isn't making power is because of the low compression, and they think the low compression could be due to it sitting for months or the engine just waring down.

This is bullshit of the very finest sort. Take the car to a more intelligent workshop.

Compressions may decrease while a car is sitting if some grunge built up somewhere hardens and perhaps stops valves from seating properly. Or the rings might get sticky in the grooves. But that sort of thing isn't usually permanent. It should come good after a brief run.

It is far more likely that the compression tester is reading low. Even if it is the same compression tester. There are so many "mechanics" that simply have no f**king idea that the performance of their test gear can change and that they need to keep it calibrated if they are going to trust their measurements.

On 8/7/2021 at 1:56 PM, SnekDoc said:

They think there's a chance that compression could come back after driving it for a couple weeks, if not they are suggesting a rebuild. 

This aligns with what I just said, although I would hope and expect it to be much faster than a couple of weeks. One good drive should do it.

  • Like 1
On 8/7/2021 at 12:27 AM, Duncan said:

Well....the battery could be flatter after sitting there all that time.....

But, no, compression doesn't sneak out on it's own.

Haven't tested with a multimeter yet but stock gauge shows around 14V.

 

On 8/6/2021 at 11:15 PM, GTSBoy said:

I'd also like to point out that ~120 psi comp readings, like your first set, if accurate, are quite low and probably low enough to explain the low power on their own. My 25Neo measures ~175-180 psi (with only slightly higher stock compression than a 26)

After a couple drives it doesn't seem to have any more power. As far as compression goes, I didn't put the car on the dyno before the turbo swap but it feels like it has less power than before and I was on stock turbos before, so it would make sense that compression is lower since the boost is higher now.

Is there anything simpler / cheaper I should have checked before going the route of a rebuild? Maybe the head gasket or valves?

On 8/8/2021 at 7:36 AM, SnekDoc said:

Is it true that if I put a little oil in the cylinders, compression test it again, and if results are the same then it is likely head gasket or valves?

Generally, yes. But there are no "rules" here, as different things can happen to any engine.

But I simply cannot think of anything that would cause all 6 cylinders to drop compression by about the same amount while sitting doing nothing. The sort of sludge hardening stuff I mentioned earlier seldom occurs evenly across an engine.

I am going to put $10 on it being something else. Maybe something messed up by the workshop.

Do a Leak down test yourself. 

Check for any leaks on the intake or exhaust manifold. 

Have someone who knows what they are doing look at your tune-they may have removed a lot of timing. Pm me or @Dose Pipe Sutututu your tune file 

Check that the cas is setup correctly with the ecu- see above

 

 

 

 

  • Like 1
On 8/7/2021 at 5:04 PM, robbo_rb180 said:

Do a Leak down test yourself. 

Check for any leaks on the intake or exhaust manifold. 

Have someone who knows what they are doing look at your tune-they may have removed a lot of timing. Pm me or @Dose Pipe Sutututu your tune file 

Check that the cas is setup correctly with the ecu- see above

I'll have to get a leakdown test kit and learn how to use it, I'm still pretty new to all this.

Looks like the tune is password protected so I'll try to get the password when they reopen in a couple days and send it over, I appreciate the help.

 

On 8/7/2021 at 9:16 PM, Dose Pipe Sutututu said:

The list of HKS parts hurt my eyes 😆

 

I knew I was going to get shit for that here

On 09/08/2021 at 5:15 AM, SnekDoc said:

I knew I was going to get shit for that here

haha, hey it's your car and you can fit whatever parts to it :)

At least you didn't replace the twin turbo bullshit with another set of twin aids - so points there!

And yes, send over the tune to either of us and we'll have a look.

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1

On that, can you get around a password on a haltech?  Send it back to the factory for a reset maybe?

If said 'shop' won't give out the password, is a new ECU the only answer?  Surely somebody has found a workaround somewhere in the world?

Or are we still waiting?

On 11/08/2021 at 7:24 PM, tridentt150v said:

On that, can you get around a password on a haltech?  Send it back to the factory for a reset maybe?

If said 'shop' won't give out the password, is a new ECU the only answer?  Surely somebody has found a workaround somewhere in the world?

Or are we still waiting?

Can't get around password lock on an Elite, but it only protects the current map. You can still load in a different base or saved map or reinitialise it and start again though. Pretty sure it's the same for a Platinum too.

On 8/11/2021 at 3:36 AM, robbo_rb180 said:

being an older platinum would be start from a base file and go from there.
@SnekDoc where are you located?

I'm in the U.S. I have another tuner I can go to that's a bit farther away that I know is good, the main reason I went to the one I did is they are much closer, I had heard good things about them wrt RBs, and the tuner that is farther away wanted to do additional things to the car that I didn't want to do / pay for at the time. My main concern right now is getting the compression back, and if that is something the shop caused that I should try to get them to cover or if I should cut my losses and go to the other tuner.

Compression doesn't just disappear. One cylinder getting low relative to others is a really, really bad sign. If it has decreased then the most likely explanation is bad ECU settings or something else have damaged the engine. Also the absolute number for compression is heavily affected by things like battery health/state of charge, whether you actually WOT properly while cranking, etc. You don't just "get compression back", you have to fix whatever is leaking compression.

  • 3 weeks later...

Had it compression tested again, readings were C1: 100, C2: 95, C3: 105, C4:110, C5: 100, C6: 110. Better than last time time and at least fairly even but still lower than originally. Air appears to be leaking into crankcase so consensus is going to need a rebuild. Time for a whole new rabbit hole and a lot more money.

Now need to find out how far I want to go upgrading things if I'm having it rebuilt. My goal was to eventually make it a track-ready 2.8 but wasn't planning on doing it this soon.

I know you guys aren't big on HKS parts, but since I'm not doing the work myself what do you think price-wise about going with a complete engine like the HKS step 2 or the Tomei one vs having a shop rebuild my engine with all the equivalent done?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • My thought is if you were just moving it forward and the upstream geometry remained the same, then no difference at all. But because the current one has the filter direct into the AFM inlet, you effectively have the best chance of a completely symmetric air flow profile upstream, and in, the AFM, whilst the aftermarket inlet thingo has a (small, to be sure) bend between the filter and the AFM. That would bias the flow to the outside of the bend (downstream of the bend) which might well reduce the size of the signal seen by the AFM, for the same total flow rate. Having said that: If you're proposing to make your inlet look like a hybrid of your existing one and the aftermarket one, such that there is no bend where the filter is clamped on... then I say it will be just fine. If there is going to be such a bend, then, if you can align the insertion of the AFM blade such that it is at right angles to the plane of the bend, then there is a better than even chance that the centreline velocity where the blade is will remain more or less the same, and the velocity will just be a little faster to the outside of that, and just a little slower to the inside. **This is not professional investment advice and you should consult a suitably qualified ouija board, tea leaves or the intestines of a goat for more accurate prognostication.
    • Hi Tao, Thanks for your reply.  It's been a while and I managed to get the valve stem seals replaced with the head on the car.  Unfortunately this didn't solve my issue, the car still smokes a lot after idling (to be honest during idle you can see a bit of blue smoke from the exhaust), same after deceleration. I will try disconnecting the valve cover breathers, do I leave the PCV valve in? By engine oil drain pipe, do you mean the turbo oil drain?
    • What about if you just give it direct 12v and earth?
    • Hi guys . Can someone help me  I bought an Android screen for my Nissan fuga but it won't turn on   
    • My guesstimate, with no real numbers to back it up, is it won't effect it greatly at all.its not a huge change in position, and I can't see the air flow changing from in turbulence that much based on distance, and what's in front of it. Johnny and Brad may have some more numbers to share from experience though.
×
×
  • Create New...