Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

I was calling a mechanic about doing a pre inspection for a car and he mentioned that mechanics don't do them anymore and it's not just as simple as pulling out spark plugs on modern cars but instead they do oscilloscope tests instead? I've never heard of this and I haven't found much information on it. Is this true?

Edited by silviaz

Correct, on modern cars you can just use scanners such as Launch X421 or an Autel.

 

For our older shit boxes, compression tests are an ok way to determine even compression between cylinders, however motor with massive duration cams will read lower compression than say a motor with stock cams. Better to do a leak down test if you want to check engine health.

33 minutes ago, Dose Pipe Sutututu said:

Correct, on modern cars you can just use scanners such as Launch X421 or an Autel.

 

For our older shit boxes, compression tests are an ok way to determine even compression between cylinders, however motor with massive duration cams will read lower compression than say a motor with stock cams. Better to do a leak down test if you want to check engine health.

Ah ok, but isn't even a 1997 car considered a modern car? That's why I was a bit confused. 

1 minute ago, silviaz said:

Ah ok, but isn't even a 1997 car considered a modern car? That's why I was a bit confused. 

No. Ancient shitbox. The sort of diagnostics that your mechanic is talking about were probably only available on top end Mercs and other leading edge stuff.

A 1997 Nissan is barely more sophisticated than a 1987 Nissan.

  • Like 2

Even a Consult 1 Nissan has a relative compression test function, it's just super jank and you have to do all your own math. You can cut the fuel injection to each cylinder, average the resulting idle RPM in the logs. If one cylinder has relatively low drop when shut down you know something is wrong with it. If there's no misfire or funny business like that then the only conclusion I can think of is low compression.

Launch X431 is great stuff btw, probably the only scan tool I've seen other than maybe the real deal Consult that will let you reset throttle position idle switch on the RB26 instead of guessing blindly at how to do it like I did in the past. It is incredibly slow though compared to NDS1 which is disappointing and the logging functions are nowhere near as powerful I think.

  • Like 1
56 minutes ago, joshuaho96 said:

reset throttle position idle switch on the RB26 instead of guessing blindly at how to do it like I did in the past

It's never been difficult on that vintage of Nissan stuff. RB20 is same same. I just used to adjust it so that even the very slightest movement off idle would cause the injectors to do the old double pulse thing (which is the accel enrich thing that they do). You literally just listen for them to go click-click-click-clickclick.

47 minutes ago, GTSBoy said:

It's never been difficult on that vintage of Nissan stuff. RB20 is same same. I just used to adjust it so that even the very slightest movement off idle would cause the injectors to do the old double pulse thing (which is the accel enrich thing that they do). You literally just listen for them to go click-click-click-clickclick.

The RB26 ECU in particular had some weird behavior, if the TPS switch was set to 0.2V when the ECU first gets power after discharging capacitors then it would decide the idle switch was off at 0.5V even though that was the factory spec. Seemingly the actual idle switch in the TPS is vestigial? Or it somehow can be reset, I never really got to the bottom of what was going on there. Regardless it was interesting to see how the scan tool also had a function to relearn the TPS idle position.

8 minutes ago, joshuaho96 said:

Seemingly the actual idle switch in the TPS is vestigial?

It was my understanding that the RB26 was the same same as the RB20. The idle position was 100% determined by the switch on the RB20. The TPS potentiometer was not used for idle at all. And in fact, the potentiometer on the RB20 was only used for the auto transmission!!! The ECU paid it no heed.

Of course, I might be wrong about that on the 26. But seeing as the 26 ECU was just a slightly glorified version of the 20 ECU, I have been willing to believe they used the same strategy. And further of course, maybe because the 26 was ITB fed they found they needed to actually use the potentiometer for the ECU. I could look it up in the manual, but really cannot be arsed. I might have even been schooled on this point before.

It was only on the R33/RB25 era that Nissan abandoned a physical switch in favour of using the potentiometer's value as the determinant for idle position (Which was a pretty shit idea considering how much trouble it's caused people over the years. It was almost certainly done because it was cheaper than having a switch too.) It is this that has led to so much confusion between RB20 and RB25 owners.

  • Like 1
4 minutes ago, GTSBoy said:

It was my understanding that the RB26 was the same same as the RB20. The idle position was 100% determined by the switch on the RB20. The TPS potentiometer was not used for idle at all. And in fact, the potentiometer on the RB20 was only used for the auto transmission!!! The ECU paid it no heed.

Of course, I might be wrong about that on the 26. But seeing as the 26 ECU was just a slightly glorified version of the 20 ECU, I have been willing to believe they used the same strategy. And further of course, maybe because the 26 was ITB fed they found they needed to actually use the potentiometer for the ECU. I could look it up in the manual, but really cannot be arsed. I might have even been schooled on this point before.

It was only on the R33/RB25 era that Nissan abandoned a physical switch in favour of using the potentiometer's value as the determinant for idle position (Which was a pretty shit idea considering how much trouble it's caused people over the years. It was almost certainly done because it was cheaper than having a switch too.) It is this that has led to so much confusion between RB20 and RB25 owners.

I honestly don't understand what's going on in the RB26. It 100% has a physical TPS idle switch. Seemingly in the R33 at least it does not pay attention to it. I didn't experiment too much but it seemed like it was purely based on a learned voltage. Maybe I'll revisit it but as far as I could tell getting the idle TPS voltage to be about 0.45V was more important than whatever the idle switch trigger point ended up being.

2 minutes ago, Dose Pipe Sutututu said:

hopefully the bin shits out $60k in cash or directly deposits that money into my bank account - if so, done deal.

What's the $60k for? replacing broken computers to stop error lights on the dash?

  • Haha 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Sounds good Hmm suppose the main thing is, how much do you care about this car? The filler doesn't make for a very good water barrier lol. If there was a tiny little bit of rust forming now, that in 3 to 5 years time becomes obvious under the paint (starts to bubble up), would it bother you? 
    • I already have the ability to datalog the voltage... what I can't do is correlate it to what the gauge is showing when I'm looking at the data at a later date. Or something like this. Except getting the oil to 125C+ involves me going 200+kmh at the track so you can imagine this is a little tricky unless I do something like note what the voltage is when I am at the top of 5th gear so I have a point to reference on. Drove car today. O2 still reading richer because hopefully not a leak instead of massive restriction I've introduced. Car really doesn't sound like a LS. It's quite strange. Pulled a bit of fuel out up top. This does potentially explain why my spark plugs looked like the car was running pretty over-rich. If I was tuning it to a ~12.7 which in reality was far richer than that in the past. It will be handy to have the dyno WB to compare my WB to to compare notes that's for sure. At this point I'm happy to just sit in the passenger seat and tune the thing given I've got about 7 million hours on the platform lol.
    • Yeah I understand you have to pay for an updated map or subscription service or something. But I can't even find a current map for Australia. My map is dated 2017, but didn't this car version still sell in Australia until 2021?   Also, just as an aside, the navigation system warns you of traffic incidences ahead.....why would they include that on a map they knew is not receiving live information. I am forever going to be warned of an incident that probably existed for 30 minutes 8 years ago.
    • Car has been sold and I am now selling leftover parts. Prices are non-negotiable as I will sell to my mechanic if it won't sell here. Prices are firm except for the Random Parts listed at the very bottom. All parts are genuine except for the S-Tune front bumper. Volk Racing TE37SL 19×10.5″ +12 5×114.3 pressed graphite with P-Zero 275 30 19 tyres [USED] $4,500 Wheels are in perfect condition, have been sitting in my garage for the past 6 years. Tyres still have 90% tread, but since they're now old, I would not recommend you drive hard on them. K-Sport Super Sport External Reservoir Coilovers (made to order) [NEW] $2,500 Front spring rate 14kg, Rear spring rate 7.5kg Fork Type. You can read all about it here (https://www.k-sportracing.com/product_detail.php?Key=12). I was going to start tracking the GTR, but never got around to it. Paid $3500 (after USD conversion and taxes). HKS Kansai Service Tower Bar [NEW] $500 Never fitted in the original Japanese box. R34 GTR S-Tune Fibreglass Bumper [NEW] $500 No mesh - No Box - No damage - just dusty. Nitto RB26 Clear Timing Cover [NEW] $50 Couldn't fit RB2630 due to bonnet clearance. HKS Piping Kit Special Type (BNR34) & Apexi Power Intake Air Filter Kit & Password JDM Adapter [USED] $1,000 Missing some rubber hoses and supports, but you get what you see. Nismo NE-1 Weldina Turbo Back Exhaust & Custom 3.5"straight pipe [USED] $1,000 Needs some love, but perfect for those who want to go back to OEM+. Bayside Blue Aluminium Vspec Bonnet/Hood [USED] $700 Came off my GTR. Unfortunately, the tips have been slightly ground down. It will need some repairing. Bride Low Max Super Seat Rails [USED] $350 The price is for both sides. Will post pictures when I get a chance. Random Parts [USED] - negotiable Standard rb26 cams (intake and exhaust) $10 Stock amber front indicators $10 Standard GTR bumper lower side grills $10 Stock amber side indicators $10 Nismo Sports Resetting ECU $50 Water reservoir $10 Stock airbox mouth $10 Stock fuel rail $10 Stock coilovers from R34 GTR Vspec $100 PM me which items you are interested in. I do work 9-5, so I will be responding daily at best. Best time for pick up is after 5 and before 7 on weekdays, or i can work something out on weekends. I will only accept cash or PayID. Pick up only - located Epping NSW area.
    • sensible choice....and all 32s should be in yellow
×
×
  • Create New...