Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

The bigger the torque spike the more of the push back in the seat feeling. As torque is proportional to acceleration.

The torque spike will be biggest with the smaller turbos running dickloads of boost, massive midrange spike.

I disagree with that...small turbos are more likely to come on early and give the car more low down torque but not a massive spike. Like the turbos used in turbo diesels, they aren't going to throw you back. And you can only run so much boost before it's outside it's efficiency range. Keep in mind we are talking about an RB25DET here, not a 2 litre. It's the big turbos that take forever to spool and throw on the power in the upper midrange...when they do it's a lightning bolt.

Anyway this "hold on feeling" is all subjective, no real point arguing it when to some people that's a turbo that holds strong throughout the range while others want a huge turbo to come on boost later and eat curbs.

I'm assuming you talking about 200kw turbos on SR motors? I found the 'push-in-seat' more epic in a couple of Jap spec s15s I drove with boost wound up high. But maybe thats because of the nature of the less torquey 4 bangers - lag.. then strong boost, RBs seem a lot mre linear and less crazy maybe because they already have the down-low torque pushing the car along..

Yeah my experience with the .86 I mentioned is on my SR. To be honest I consider a 2L 4pot to be more brutal in nature to a 6cyl of whatever size.

Whether it be some sort of lag and zap effect or that they actually product better torque for power is a difference of opinion really. I am happy for you to come and get an impression of my car once I change the exhaust housing. You will see there is no lag and zap effect but only a really strong pull effect through the midrange.

As a point of reference the TD05-18g SR I did recently made over 530nm on only 207kw, thats 300kw skyline material and it had peak torque at 4200rpm. I believe brutal delivery at a low RPM showcases actual torque, not that linear wind up toy feeling everyone normally misconceives as torque (pretty much what my setup has now, with 440nm at 5000rpm).

I reckon its the rate of increase of torque = crazy rush and quite often wheelspin.

Yes torque does give you the push in the back but if it is just slowly increasing then it doesnt feel like a rush. Remember someone posting about the LS7 Corvette ZR1 and saying it actually felt slower then his worked jap car with large turbo except when you looked at the speedo it would kill it. To me that is because the Corvette would have quite a flat torque curve whereas the jap car with large turbo would have no torque, no torque then a steep rise in torque.

Hahaha yeah but you're a drifter :P

For a street car just spinning your wheels at the wrong time can mean confiscation of your car for a month I think it is now.

I believe in Victoria it's now 25 to life.

I disagree with that...small turbos are more likely to come on early and give the car more low down torque but not a massive spike. Like the turbos used in turbo diesels, they aren't going to throw you back. And you can only run so much boost before it's outside it's efficiency range. Keep in mind we are talking about an RB25DET here, not a 2 litre. It's the big turbos that take forever to spool and throw on the power in the upper midrange...when they do it's a lightning bolt.

I wasn't talking small turbos, just smaller turbos. Eg one of hypergears 280kw turbos is going to give a bigger torque spike than his lag monster 320kw ones.

Harey I agree with what you are saying, it is the spike that does it really.

Edited by Rolls

I reckon its the rate of increase of torque = crazy rush and quite often wheelspin.

Yes torque does give you the push in the back but if it is just slowly increasing then it doesnt feel like a rush. Remember someone posting about the LS7 Corvette ZR1 and saying it actually felt slower then his worked jap car with large turbo except when you looked at the speedo it would kill it. To me that is because the Corvette would have quite a flat torque curve whereas the jap car with large turbo would have no torque, no torque then a steep rise in torque.

I used to have this debate all the time with my old man. Theres an obvious point where usable torque comes into play, that being the happy area in your powerband. V8s feel linear because they make all their torque too early, its the energy of a big motor that makes them fast. But imagine you could harness all the wheel spinning torque they make at 200rpm and translate that to full traction acceleration... now that would be crazy.

The problem is there are sheer limitations of that sort of thing, like tyres and road conditions.. But thats where our little turbo toys come into play. We start with a boring little donk and add a turbo onto it. The right turbo and cam choice can shift the torque around to suit what gear ratios were limited by, and create a fast car.

I once built a front wheel drive turbo, most epic car I have ever owned. The theory of the turning wheels pulling you around a corner was a total win (driving wheels in a RWD point straight, so how can you expect it to propell you around a corner?). I set about finding the perfect balance between power and delivery to make the car really quick through the hills. I was finding as an NA it would understeer because it had not enough power or not enough energy in certain gears, but then the right cam/turbo choice ended up with only 120kw but a car that could punch through corners 2 gears above what it was prior (with the obvious speed increase to match).

End of the day its not all about how much torque or power or even where... But how its delivered. Said it before and will say it again, delivery is KING.

I believe in Victoria it's now 25 to life.

NSW is no different... been there, done that.

Well arent you the pot calling the kettle black lol, Mr Corvette LS7 ra ra ra :nyaanyaa:

Its all relevant anyway, were talking about the rush you get from certain turbos and if thats torque or just the 'feeling' it gives you. I did my best to eleborate on my theories by describing how I utilised this 'rush' torque feeling to better drive a car. Be it FWD or not. Trying to describe that the feeling is relevant to actual torque and speed.

About as relevant as comparing it to a V8 :whistling: which Id say is entirely relevant in open discussion. Sorry if I didnt make my point clear enough, I hope I have now. Its hard to put everything down when at work.

I agree with Rolls and Harey saying it is the torque delivery that you feel. My G3 only really comes on strong at about 5000rpm, and you get a little bit of a shove but nothing extreme. Most likely due to the lack of VCT. Comparing that to a mates 25 with an almost identical setup to me except with a smaller TD05, so less torque and less power, his turbo comes on song at about 4000 and it gives you a real shove. My car is still quicker, his just feels more brutal.

I need a retune dammit happy.gif

As a point of reference the TD05-18g SR I did recently made over 530nm on only 207kw, thats 300kw skyline material and it had peak torque at 4200rpm.

No it didn't... Power is directly related to torque. If it made 530Nm at 4200RPM it is making 233kw at 4200RPM.

I just read all the replies so now I might ask you all a question

and also let you know what I was talking about when I mean "push back in seat"

So right now I am running a stock 33 with a greddy profec 2

Its running about 11PSI and bleeds to about 10PSI

When I take off in 1st and also putting my foot down in 2nd gear it gives me the rush feeling of I better hold on. No wheel spin or anything just that pressure that sits you in your seat

I was wondering if the SS1PU will do this but a fair bit harsher because its not a stock turbo or because the spool is close to the same as a stock turbo only the end result in kw gain changes?

Hope I am not to confusing guys :rolleyes:

**edit** The car wont be stock when the SS1PU is installed it will have all the extras to get 250rwkw

Edited by Kasko

I was wondering if the SS1PU will do this but a fair bit harsher because its not a stock turbo or because the spool is close to the same as a stock turbo only the end result in kw gain changes?

Hope I am not to confusing guys :rolleyes:

**edit** The car wont be stock when the SS1PU is installed it will have all the extras to get 250rwkw

Yes it will do it harsher because it is making a solid 25-50% more torque in the midrange. I think this will be the best turbo for the feeling you want. I have a gcg turbo that comes on strong about 4k, and I describe it as the same thing, about 3.5-4k it just snaps you back in the seat due to the midrange, it then tapers off towards redline.

I agree with Rolls and Harey saying it is the torque delivery that you feel. My G3 only really comes on strong at about 5000rpm, and you get a little bit of a shove but nothing extreme. Most likely due to the lack of VCT. Comparing that to a mates 25 with an almost identical setup to me except with a smaller TD05, so less torque and less power, his turbo comes on song at about 4000 and it gives you a real shove. My car is still quicker, his just feels more brutal.

I need a retune dammit happy.gif

Hahaha but thats not what I am saying. I am saying the G3 should give you much more of a rush due to the change in torque (steepness of the torque curve). The smaller TD05 should be quite a gradual build of boost whereas the G3 typically will be more nothing and then holy sh*t. You need to get your setup sorted so its like the latter :)

Im so fricken excited for all the things happening to the car in the next few months!

When everyone was talking about the big laggy turbos making the feeling im looking for I was thinking about how I get the feeling from my stock one launches in 1st and and that surly isnt a laggy turbo

Hahaha but thats not what I am saying. I am saying the G3 should give you much more of a rush due to the change in torque (steepness of the torque curve). The smaller TD05 should be quite a gradual build of boost whereas the G3 typically will be more nothing and then holy sh*t. You need to get your setup sorted so its like the latter :)

That's... Exactly what I said. Lol.

Most likely because of my lack of VCT, my G3 doesn't build torque very quickly. It still creates a lot of torque, but it's not a steep curve. My mates TD05 actually has a steeper torque curve, despite being more responsive. It makes less peak torque and less peak power, but the shape of his curve gives his car more of the rush.

Kasko, you need to be aware that the feeling you're after doesn't last, you do get used to it. Like you keep referring to your stock turbo giving the feeling you're after, yet if I was to go for a ride in a stock GTT I bet it would feel like I was in a Getz.

A good way to reset that feeling is to have it off the road for 3 months, you forget what it is like completely, get back in it and go wholy shit this is ridiculous all over again heh.

A good way to reset that feeling is to have it off the road for 3 months, you forget what it is like completely, get back in it and go wholy shit this is ridiculous all over again heh.

This is what I do :D Having another daily is great.

No it didn't... Power is directly related to torque. If it made 530Nm at 4200RPM it is making 233kw at 4200RPM.

No worries, DVS JEZ on this forum tuned it - he has the dyno data for it also :action-smiley-069:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Will have a look at that. I cant see any leaks 
    • Put another overflow bottle (ie, a 1.25 coke bottle or similar) under the overflow hose and see if it is being pushed out there or if it is disappearing into the engine.
    • Staring on a stand is no issue. You just have to wire everything up, give it fuel and cross your fingers that the stand is robust enough. Arranging the inlet plumbing is often the hardest part, without any surrounding structure to hand some of it from. No need for coolant if you only want to run it for <1 minute. As to the gearbox - I think the little Aisin box is a bit stronger than the other small Nissan boxes that went behind SRs, but I wouldn't be too keen to test its limits with the torque of a boosted 25. I don't know if you can retain the box and the tailshaft. The box won't connect to the RB without an adapter of some sort, which is either a plate that will push the engine forward (which is not good for fitting it into the bay's available space) or push the box back, which messes with the box position and tailshaft length - OR - cut and shut work on the bellhousing, which is a long way from "least modification". I'd be buying a new 370Z 6 speed or similar, doing what has to be done to that to make it fit RB (ie, cut and shut bellhousing) and the requisite tailshaft custom/mods.
    • Hi Everyone I am from West Pennant Hills in NSW. Been too busy until recently to attend to my RB25DET Series 2 engine until recently. I am planning to stick it into the S15 shell at this stage, unless a nice SR20DET turns up... For now, i am going to try and get the RB25 running and working well then decide what gearbox to use. My preference is to retain the SR20DET  6 speed gearbox and tail shaft to retain as much and least modifications as i can avoid. I am an old guy and won't be doing any heavy drifting so i don't need a bullet proof gearbox Does anyone have experience with starting the RB on a stand? I got everything setup as much as I can with the info i can find... endless searching and videos on Youtube I would be great to get some pointers Cheers Songo
    • Hey all, Recently have had my s1 r33 gtr serviced and noticed my coolant reservoir was topped up to the max line. Took the car out for 1 yesterday and noticed today the reservoir is completely empty.  Any ideas? Radiator is full
×
×
  • Create New...