Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

I'm getting bored with my R34 and am thinking of changing to a 04/05 V8 Monaro. There arent any around here to test drive so I was wondering if there is anyone who has driven both can give me some advice about what I can expect in handling/performance differences.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/336137-r34-gtt-vs-late-model-v8-monaro/
Share on other sites

I'm getting bored with my R34 and am thinking of changing to a 04/05 V8 Monaro. There arent any around here to test drive so I was wondering if there is anyone who has driven both can give me some advice about what I can expect in handling/performance differences.

monaro is quicker than a stock gtt, doesn't handle as well as a stock gtt though.

Throw on a few bolt ons, raise turbo pressure, tune and gtt is better in every way.

if you're bored of the gtt then give the monaro a go, keep in mind they are two very different cars and they are pretty hard to compare, depends on the individual person.

Also posting on a skyline forum you are already setting yourself up for a biassed response.

good luck

In a straight line the monaro would prob beat the stock 34, but come to a corner the 34's chassis will be able to carry the speed through. If your bored its obviously upgrading suspension/turbo time! A properly modded skyline is never boring! :D

Any N/A Monaro you say? :D

I recommend doing the change. If you're bored of your R34, modifying it will only sustain enjoyment for a little while longer. Monaro is a completely different car, I think you'll like it just on it being different. I'd do the same swing to an R34 if I was getting bored of a Monaro. LS engines are very easy to modify, you'll enjoy Commodore parts availability and pricing.

I beg to differ.

If you have a Monaro with some mild mods such as an intake and exhaust VS a modded R34 (exhaust, intake, boost, FMIC, computer system, tune), the Monaro and the Skyline would be very much on par in all areas. If you had both on a track, the Monaro would be faster down the 1/4 mile, and around a racetrack, the Monaro and Skyline would be very closely matched.

Remember, a very lightly modded Monaro (with a free-flowing exhaust and intake) would be making somewhere in the vicinity of 350rwhp, whereas a mildly modded R34 (as above) would be making 250-280rwhp. The monaro has a shitload more torque thanks to a larger capacity motor and of course the 2 extra cyliners.

Obviously if you drive both, you will notice the difference, as the Monaro isn't exactly a light car (weighing in somewhere around the 1600kg mark), and the R34 is around the ~1450kg mark.

At the end of the day it's personal choice. Go drive a Monaro and take your time to think about it. Buy what you prefer to drive, buy what you will enjoy to drive more...don't impulse buy or you will regret it.

If you want something different why not go down the AWD path?

My mate and I test drove an Evo 8 on the weekend, it was nuts. The owner was obviously a skilled driver, but the speed he took these corners and speed traps in the wet was scary. The raw acceleration was mental too. Sure top end it might run out of puff, but shooting around the streets it was neck breakingly quick.

+1 For Evo 8 MR

i looked at a few and they can now be had for around 31-32 Mark, although advertised for 35-36 Mark

There bloody nice to drive... it was a night mare to pick which to Buy/ import (in my case R34 GTR vs Evo 8 MR)

No clue on the Monaro, I will say a free flowing LS engine, is a very nice sounding engine...

regardless, Test Drive before you make up you mind.... Big mistake otherwise

Buy my dads :thumbsup:

http://www.carsales.com.au/all-cars/privat...igy&trecs=1

But in all honestly it comes down to whether you are keeping the cars stock or doing mild mods or going all out. Once modifications come into play its a whole new ball game. The Monaros really start to shine with a supercharger on them and I gaurantee if you drove my dads car you would want one straight away, it puts my car to shame.

Any N/A Monaro you say? :thumbsup:

No i didn't say any. To clarify, i mean most stock capacity, mildly modded LS1s

I beg to differ.

If you have a Monaro with some mild mods such as an intake and exhaust VS a modded R34 (exhaust, intake, boost, FMIC, computer system, tune), the Monaro and the Skyline would be very much on par in all areas. If you had both on a track, the Monaro would be faster down the 1/4 mile, and around a racetrack, the Monaro and Skyline would be very closely matched.

Remember, a very lightly modded Monaro (with a free-flowing exhaust and intake) would be making somewhere in the vicinity of 350rwhp, whereas a mildly modded R34 (as above) would be making 250-280rwhp. The monaro has a shitload more torque thanks to a larger capacity motor and of course the 2 extra cyliners.

Obviously if you drive both, you will notice the difference, as the Monaro isn't exactly a light car (weighing in somewhere around the 1600kg mark), and the R34 is around the ~1450kg mark.

At the end of the day it's personal choice. Go drive a Monaro and take your time to think about it. Buy what you prefer to drive, buy what you will enjoy to drive more...don't impulse buy or you will regret it.

1600kg is being a bit kind to the Monaro, isn't it? Add to that the fact that a lot of them are auto, so from a rolling start, where the skyline will be on boost straight away, the monaro is going to want to have a fair bit more hp to keep up.

this isn't a pissing contest, however. i agree, best bet for the OP is to give one a go.

Board?!

Buy a R34 GTR.

Stock GTTs are slow.... I had a run with one on my mums saab 95 linear (130kw at fly, fwd) and lost by 1-1.5 car lengths around 130 from a 20 rolling start....

"Ask any racer, it don't matter if you win by an inch or a mile. Winning's winning."

:thumbsup:

Buy my dads :thumbsup:

http://www.carsales.com.au/all-cars/privat...igy&trecs=1

But in all honestly it comes down to whether you are keeping the cars stock or doing mild mods or going all out. Once modifications come into play its a whole new ball game. The Monaros really start to shine with a supercharger on them and I gaurantee if you drove my dads car you would want one straight away, it puts my car to shame.

nice car^

wish I had a dad like that :)

tbh tho mine is into FX-FJ holdens, in particular fj panelvans. got a handful of them in various states.

he was going to buy a yellow new monaro back in 2000 but was held up with shotgun on the test drive (it would have been mine to buy after 3yrs)

never did buy a monaro, went to nissan patrols instead. being 2m tall I couldnt even fit in the front seats let alone behind the steering wheel!

so my brother got the opportunity to buy a patrol off him instead. me, Im still waiting for my monaro

My wife has an SS Ute 6 speed manual, trust me stick with the skyline. There clunky build quality is crap everything falls apart. Gearbox feels like a tractor. Engine in stock form isn't that torquie, Basically not that great to drive. Mod your skyline 400 ponies kicking out the back will get you back into it

nice car^

wish I had a dad like that :)

tbh tho mine is into FX-FJ holdens, in particular fj panelvans. got a handful of them in various states.

he was going to buy a yellow new monaro back in 2000 but was held up with shotgun on the test drive (it would have been mine to buy after 3yrs)

never did buy a monaro, went to nissan patrols instead. being 2m tall I couldnt even fit in the front seats let alone behind the steering wheel!

so my brother got the opportunity to buy a patrol off him instead. me, Im still waiting for my monaro

No Shit, i remeber that on the news. Monaro's were only out for like a week and it got highjacked, near adelaide oval? Would have been pretty scary for your old man, good enough reason not to buy one i'm thinking! :thumbsup:

I have a direct comparison, my old man has a VZ series monaro with a tune (225rwkw) and I have an R34 GTT with a cooler exhaust and boost (190rwkw). Mine will just beat him in a straight line, as soon as a corner comes the R34 kills it.

It depends what sort of person you are, are you into the look and feel of your car or the sheer performance of it? If you enjoy the look and feel of a car, then a change may be great and you can enjoy something different. If its the performance side, then the one that is more modded will win haha.

So start modding! I went for a ride in the hypergear R33 with 300rwkw (but only running 270rwkw on the night) and it was spaz. It gave you a real thrill. Plus once you hit the speed, the skyline can hold more of it through the corner. My vote is for the R34. The monaro is a great car but more straight line oriented and a great cruising car.

Edited by Harey
No Shit, i remeber that on the news. Monaro's were only out for like a week and it got highjacked, near adelaide oval? Would have been pretty scary for your old man, good enough reason not to buy one i'm thinking! :thumbsup:

yup, carjacked on war memorial drive.

put him off the monaro thats for sure..... never mind the fact the thieves were meth-heads on a crime spree; random opportunity to carjack a new monaro so they took it

Buy my dads :thumbsup:

http://www.carsales.com.au/all-cars/privat...igy&trecs=1

But in all honestly it comes down to whether you are keeping the cars stock or doing mild mods or going all out. Once modifications come into play its a whole new ball game. The Monaros really start to shine with a supercharger on them and I gaurantee if you drove my dads car you would want one straight away, it puts my car to shame.

Love the QLD mod plate, "yeah mate she looks good" and passed. No emission tests or engineering certificates etc.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • From there, it is really just test and assemble. Plug the adapter cables from the unit into the back of the screen, then the other side to the car harness. Don't forget all the other plugs too! Run the cables behind the unit and screw it back into place (4 screws) and you should now have 3 cables to run from the top screen to the android unit. I ran them along the DS of the other AV units in the gap between their backets and the console, and used some corrugated tubing on the sharp edges of the bracket so the wires were safe. Plug the centre console and lower screen in temporarily and turn the car to ACC, the AV should fire up as normal. Hold the back button for 3 sec and Android should appear on the top screen. You need to set the input to Aux for audio (more on that later). I put the unit under the AC duct in the centre console, with the wifi antenna on top of the AC duct near the shifter, the bluetooth antenna on the AC duct under the centre console The GPS unit on top of the DS to AC duct; they all seem to work OK there are are out of the way. Neat cable routing is a pain. For the drive recorder I mounted it near the rear view mirror and run the cable in the headlining, across the a pillar and then down the inside of the a pillar seal to the DS lower dash. From there it goes across and to one USB input for the unit. The second USB input is attached to the ECUtec OBD dongle and the 3rd goes to the USB bulkhead connected I added in the centre console. This is how the centre console looks "tidied" up Note I didn't install the provided speaker, didn't use the 2.5mm IPod in line or the piggyback loom for the Ipod or change any DIP switches; they seem to only be required if you need to use the Ipod input rather than the AUX input. That's it, install done, I'll follow up with a separate post on how the unit works, but in summary it retains all factory functions and inputs (so I still use my phone to the car for calls), reverse still works like factory etc.
    • Place the new daughterboard in the case and mount it using the 3 small black rivets provided, and reconnect the 3 factory ribbon cables to the new board Then, use the 3 piggyback cables from the daughterboard into the factory board on top (there are stand offs in the case to keep them apart. and remember to reconnect the antenna and rear cover fan wires. 1 screw to hold the motherboard in place. Before closing the case, make a hole in the sticker covering a hole in the case and run the cable for the android unit into the plug there. The video forgot this step, so did I, so will you probably. Then redo the 4 screws on back, 2 each top and bottom, 3 each side and put the 2 brackets back on.....all ready to go and not that tricky really.      
    • Onto the android unit. You need to remove the top screen because there is a daughterboard to put inside the case. Each side vent pops out from clips; start at the bottom and carefully remove upwards (use a trim remover tool to avoid breaking anything). Then the lower screen and controls come out, 4 screws, a couple of clips (including 3 flimsy ones at the top) and 3 plugs on the rear. Then the upper screen, 4 screws and a bunch of plugs and she is out. From there, remove the mounting brackets (2 screws each), 4 screws on the rear, 2 screws top and bottom and 3 screws holding in the small plates on each side. When you remove the back cover (tight fit), watch out for the power cable for the fan, I removed it so I could put the back aside. The mainboard is held in by 1 screw in the middle, 1 aerial at the top and 3 ribbon cables. If you've ever done any laptop stuff the ribbon cables are OK to work with, just pop up the retainer and they slide out. If you are not familiar just grab a 12 year old from an iphone factory, they will know how it works The case should now look like this:
    • Switching the console was tricky. First there were 6 screws to remove, and also the little adapter loom and its screws had to come out. Also don't forget to remove the 2 screws holding the central locking receiver. Then there are 4 clips on either side....these were very tight in this case and needed careful persuading with a long flat screw driver....some force required but not enough to break them...this was probably the fiddliest part of the whole job. In my case I needed both the wiring loom and the central locking receiver module to swap across to the new one. That was it for the console, so "assembly is the reverse of disassembly"
    • But first....while I was there, I also swapped across the centre console box for the other style where the AV inputs don't intrude into the (very limited !) space.  Part# was 96926-4GA0A, 284H3-4GA0B, 284H3-4GA0A. (I've already swapped the top 12v socket for a USB bulkhead in this pic, it fit the hole without modification:) Comparison of the 2: Basically to do the console you need to remove the DS and PS side console trim (they slide up and back, held in by clips only) Then remove the back half of the console top trim with the cupholders, pops up, all clips again but be careful at the front as it is pretty flimsy. Then slide the shifter boot down, remove the spring clip, loose it forever somewhere in the car the pull the shift knob off. Remove the tiny plastic piece on DS near "P" and use something thin and long (most screwdrivers won't fit) to push down the interlock and put the shifter down in D for space. There is one screw at the front, then the shifter surround and ashtray lift up. There are 3 or 4 plugs underneath and it is off. Next is the rear cover of the centre console; you need to open the console lid, pop off the trim covering the lid hinge and undo the 2rd screw from the driver's side (the rest all need to come out later so you can do them all now and remove the lid) Then the rear cover unclips (6 clips), start at the top with a trim tool pulling backwards. Once it is off there are 2 screws facing rearwards to remove (need a short phillips for these) and you are done with the rear of the console. There are 4 plugs at the A/V box to unclip Then there are 2 screws at the front of the console, and 2 clips (pull up and back) and the console will come out.
×
×
  • Create New...